Sequence of Returns Risk: Why the First Years of Retirement Matter Most
Two retirees can earn the same average return over 25 years and still end up in very different places. The difference often comes down to timing: whether the bad years happened early in retirement, while they were withdrawing money, or later on. That's a sequence of returns risk, and it's one of the biggest risks retirees face that most people have never heard of. Here's how it works and how retirees plan around it.
Key Takeaways
- Sequence of returns risk is the risk that poor market returns early in retirement, combined with ongoing withdrawals, permanently shrink your savings.
- The same losses do less damage later in retirement or while you're still working and adding money.
- No strategy removes the risk. Each common approach trades some of it for a different cost or limitation.
- Flexible withdrawals, a cash reserve, Social Security timing, and guaranteed income sources are the main tools retirees use.
- The years just before and just after you retire are when this deserves the most attention.
What Sequence of Returns Risk Means
While you're working, a market decline is painful but temporary for most savers. You keep contributing, you aren't selling, and your account has years to recover. Once you retire and start withdrawing, that changes. If the market falls while you're taking money out, you have to sell more shares to get the same income. Those shares are gone, and they can't participate in any recovery.
That's why the order of returns matters, not just the average. A decline in the first few years of retirement, when your balance is largest and your withdrawals are just starting, can affect how long your money lasts far more than the same decline 20 years later, when there's less left to draw from and fewer years of withdrawals ahead.
FINRA's investor education materials make the same point. The stock market goes up and down, and there have been many short-term periods with returns well below the historical average. Given that uncertainty, FINRA says, along with market swings and longer life expectancies, retirees have good reason to be conservative with withdrawals, especially during the first years of retirement. (Source:
finra.org/sites/default/files/InvestorDocument/p117404.pdf, FINRA, Early Retirement Seminars 101)
Why Averages Can Be Misleading
Retirement projections often assume a steady average return every year. Real markets don't work that way. They rise and fall unevenly, and a plan built on a smooth average can look much sturdier on paper than it is. That's also why you should be cautious of any pitch built around a high assumed return. The real question for a retiree isn't just "what will I earn on average?" but "what happens to my plan if the bad years come first?"
Ways Retirees Plan Around It
There's no way to eliminate sequence risk, but there are ways to reduce how much it can hurt. Each one comes with a trade-off.
Flexible withdrawals. Taking less in down years and more in strong years means selling fewer shares when prices are low. The cost is that your income becomes less predictable, and it only works if part of your spending can be trimmed when needed.
A cash or short-term reserve. Some retirees set aside a portion of their savings in cash or short-term holdings to cover a period of withdrawals, so they don't have to sell investments during a decline. The trade-off is that money held in cash tends to earn less and can lose ground to inflation over time.
Social Security timing. Social Security is paid for life and adjusted for inflation, and it isn't affected by market swings. Delaying your claim, up to 70, increases that guaranteed income. The catch is that you usually have to draw more from savings while you wait, which can add to sequence risk in those early years. We cover the timing trade-offs in our post on retirement income planning.
Guaranteed income products. Some retirees use an annuity to cover part of their essential expenses with income that doesn't depend on the market. Annuities come with real limitations: fees, surrender charges if you need the money early, reduced flexibility, and guarantees that depend on the insurer's claims-paying ability. We go through those pros and cons in detail in Annuities: Pros and Cons. Insurance and annuity products are offered through Leonard Financial Solutions, so we may earn a commission if you buy one through us, which gives us a financial incentive to recommend them.
A diversified mix of investments. Spreading savings across different types of investments can soften the effect of a decline in any one area. Diversification doesn't guarantee a profit or protect against losses in a falling market, and the right mix depends on your timeline, your other income, and how much risk you can live with.
The New Jersey Piece
Where your withdrawals come from also matters for taxes. New Jersey doesn't tax Social Security, but it does tax pension and IRA income, and residents 62 and older may be able to exclude some of it if their total income is $150,000 or less. (Source:
nj.gov/treasury/taxation/njit7.shtml, NJ Division of Taxation, Retirement Income Exclusions) A plan to draw from a cash reserve or a Roth account during a down market, rather than a traditional IRA, can affect your state and federal tax bill in the same year. That's worth looking at alongside your
tax planning, not separately.
Where This Fits Into Your Bigger Retirement Picture
You can't control when markets fall, but you can control how prepared your plan is if they fall right after you retire. That usually means deciding ahead of time where your income will come from in a bad year, so you're not making those decisions under stress. The years just before and just after you retire are when it matters most.
If you're getting close to retirement and want to see how your plan would hold up if markets don't cooperate early on, our
retirement income planning team works with retirees across
New Jersey. Book your retirement review (/contact) or call 856-444-LIFE, and we'll walk through it with your actual numbers.
Leonard Financial Solutions offers retirement planning, tax strategy and Medicare coordination. Insurance and annuity products are offered through Leonard Financial Solutions. Products and services described on this website may not be available in all states. Not all services are advisory services. Consult a qualified professional for advice specific to your situation.












